Crafting a Dream: A Custom Build in Caswell Heights by Rufty Homes

Nestled within the historic charm of Raleigh’s Hayes Barton neighborhood, Caswell Heights stands as a testament to timeless design and thoughtful community planning. Among its tree-lined streets and classic architecture,  a thoughtfully designed custom home—crafted by Rufty Homes—stands as a tribute to intentional living, enduring relationships, and expert craftsmanship.

Rufty Homes, with over 35 years of experience, has long been recognized as one of the Triangle’s premier luxury custom home builders. Their commitment to quality, integrity, and personalized service has earned them accolades and a loyal clientele.

After living in a 100-year-old Georgian home just down the street for over two decades, the homeowners sought a new beginning that would simplify their lifestyle while honoring their personal history in the neighborhood. The homeowners embarked on this journey with a clear vision: to build a home that reflected their lifestyle while respecting the neighborhood's aesthetic.

“We raised our family in that old house—it was beautiful and sentimental. But we were ready for something that made sense for the next phase of life,” said the homeowner.

A corner lot in Caswell Heights offered the perfect opportunity to reimagine a home without leaving the community they loved. To bring that vision to life, they turned to longtime architectural collaborator Carter Skinner and quickly selected Rufty Homes to manage the build.

“We talked to a couple of different builders, but we felt comfortable with Rufty because of their great reputation and budgeting process,” the homeowner explained. “We were trying to downsize, and they gave us confidence they could keep us on track.”

From the outset, Rufty Homes engaged in a collaborative process, ensuring that every detail—from the home's orientation to its interior finishes—aligned with the homeowners' aspirations. The collaboration between the homeowners, Rufty Homes, architect Carter Skinner, interior designer Katherine Connell, and landscape designer Frank Liggett was deliberate and highly personalized. Every detail—down to wall placement for art and materials for the facade—was hand-selected with purpose.

“We didn’t want a statement house—we wanted something that fit into the neighborhood,” said the homeowner. “People constantly tell us, ‘Your home looks like it’s always been here.’ That’s the best compliment we could get.”

Throughout the construction process, Rufty Homes maintained open lines of communication, providing regular updates and accommodating adjustments as needed. This level of transparency and flexibility ensured that the homeowners felt supported and confident in their decisions. The result is a home that not only meets but exceeds their expectations.

While the home sits on a smaller lot than their previous property, the landscaping by Myatt and the privacy-focused design created a peaceful retreat. Rufty Homes prioritized preserving mature trees and optimizing natural light, resulting in a residence that feels both expansive and intimately connected to its surroundings. The exterior showcases classic design elements, while the interior boasts modern amenities and open-concept living spaces that cater to contemporary lifestyles.

“It’s not a mansion, but it’s perfect for us. It’s understated, beautiful, and just feels right,” said the homeowner.

One of the defining features of the home is its custom-cut stone exterior, inspired by the homeowner’s grandparents’ home. With every piece hand-cut on site, the project became a true labor of craftsmanship.

“I have to give Rufty and the stonemasons credit—it was a real craftsman’s job,” he shared. “That stonework, it’s what makes the house unique. It’s not just a façade, it’s part of the story.”

Inside, the home was built for both beauty and function—designed with the future in mind. With a primary suite, dual offices, zero-entry shower, and aging-in-place features, the layout supports comfortable living on a single level.

“We can live on one floor as we age, and still host family in style,” he said.

Rufty Homes’ flexibility and responsiveness stood out throughout the process. As changes arose—from art lighting systems to functional adjustments like linen closets and doors—the team responded with professionalism and care.

“We made a lot of decisions on the fly, and Rufty was always accommodating,” he said. “They really worked with us, not against us.”

Beyond the physical structure, this project underscores Rufty Homes' dedication to building lasting relationships. Their approach goes beyond mere construction; it's about understanding and bringing to life the unique narratives of each client. In the end, this Caswell Heights residence isn’t just a house—it’s a masterclass in collaborative design, intentional living, and the enduring quality that Rufty Homes brings to every custom build.

“The quality of the home is outstanding. There was no compromise,” the homeowner said. “And that’s what Rufty delivers—homes that feel personal, livable, and timeless.”

For those considering a custom home in the Raleigh area, Rufty Homes offers a blend of expertise, craftsmanship, and personalized service that ensures each project is both distinctive and enduring. Their work in Caswell Heights serves as a shining example of what’s possible when vision and skill converge.

To explore more about Rufty Homes custom home builds, check out our expansive portfolio. If you would like to get in touch, fill out a contact form today!